Extra Eisners - BEST SINGLE ISSUE/ONE-SHOT - These Savage Shores #5

Overall, THESE SAVAGE SHORES #5 follows through with the same slow-burn carried throughout the previous issues, with the right amount of reveals and a rewarding ending that sinks its teeth in. -Brittany Matter

Read More

Extra Eisners - BEST PUBLICATION FOR KIDS - Lucky Stars by Aron Nel Steinke

Aron Nel Steinke’s “Mr. Wolf’s Class” books, of which “Lucky Stars” is the third volume, have been wholesomely winsome and charming. The latest installment in the series shows the care and growth the character and their relationships, which have blossomed since their first day of school (which is the subject of the first book). As ever, Mr. Wolf and his class of rambunctious (but sweet) fourth graders learn life lessons, develop deep friendships, and overcome the challenges of growing up.

Read More

Extra Eisners - BEST DIGITAL COMIC - Gryffen: Galaxy's Most Wanted

Gryffen: Galaxy’s Most Wanted is weird. It’s intense. It will bring all kinds of emotions to the surface and it will make you crave more, because the world is so fully-realized and the characters are so compelling.

Read More

Extra Eisners - BEST PAINTER/DIGITAL ARTIST - Alex Alice

Alex Alice’s. The French cartoonist behind Castle in the Stars, the graphic novel series at First Second that follows a collection of adventurers as they race to master a substance called aether and become the first to the Moon and beyond, is a unique talent. Few people would be able to deliver a story that could most easily be described as “what if Hayao Miyazaki and Jules Verne collaborated?” and live up to that kind of buildup. And yet, Alice does, and does so in brilliant fashion.

Read More

Extra Eisners - BEST PUBLICATION DESIGN - Tom Muller (Dawn of X)

One of the great unspoken laws of comics is “in-house style” sucks on ice. You know it. I know it. Even your older brother’s friend who still wears the jean vest and swears by his holocovers of the 90’s Rai knows it, though he would be caught dead on the train tracks before he would admit it.

Read More

Extra Eisners - BEST WRITER/ARTIST - Michel Fiffe

My one holdup when nominating Michel Fiffe for the Extra Eisner project is that the dude must have shelf-full of Eisner anyway, and he doesn’t really need another (even fictional) one. Imagine my surprise (shock! Terror!) when I discovered Fiffe’s shelves are quite safe from the threat of Eisner trophy damages: he was given the prize not once!

Read More

Extra Eisners - BEST COVER ARTIST - Matteo Scalera

To those like me who are completely willing to blind-buy a comic based on its art style, a good cover art can be a dangerous thing. Cheesy name, mediocre plotline be damned, if the cover has that dreamy coloring and those pleasing lines that instantly scream serotonin boost, it’s getting bagged and boarded ASAP. One such artist that never fails to deliver on that front is Matteo Scalera.

Read More

Extra Eisners - BEST WRITER - Simon Spurrier

All this to say: I wish Simon Spurrier had been nominated for an Eisner. Perhaps he will some day, but it’s painful to see a writer put out the best work of his career so far and receive no accolades for it. -Hussein Wasiti

Read More

Extra Eisners - BEST ADAPTATION FROM ANOTHER MEDIUM - Star Wars: Lost Stars

The manga adaptation of Claudia Gray's novel, Yusaku Komiyama's Star Wars: Lost Stars, is a heart-wrenching romance set among the rise of the Empire and the Rebellion against it. The book explores how citizens of the galaxy could be seduced by the unity and opportunity offered by the authoritarianism of the Empire provides. Eventually, the true nature of the Empire can no longer be denied or overlooked and tough choices, obviously, must be made. The characters are fascinating and the story is layered and poignant, touching on classism, cultural prejudice, the effects of war, and more.

Read More

Extra Eisners - BEST U.S. EDITION OF INTERNATIONAL MATERIAL (ASIA) - No Longer Human by Junji Ito

I am the first to admit that I am something of a neophyte when it comes to manga. As a critic, I’ve tried to allow myself room to grow in that regard and I feel like I’ve done a decent job at this last year. I resolved myself to take in more of the “canon” of this massive medium, both in reading for work and for pleasure throughout this ongoing Year of Hell that we’ve all collectively experienced. And am I truly glad I did, because that allowed me to experience No Longer Human.

Read More

Extra Eisners - BEST COLORING - Brad Simpson

If you were following indie comics in 2019, especially the ones with a flavor of the weird in them, you probably read something colored by Brad Simpson. The standouts to me were Black Stars Above and Coffin Bound, two of last year’s finest examples of a very good year for weird horror.

Read More